Comparison

Beehiiv vs Substack for Creators

Beehiiv vs Substack for creators: the 10% fee against a monthly plan, free-subscriber caps, ads, and automations. Official pages checked November 19, 2026.

Affiliate disclosure. If you buy through a link on this page, we may earn a commission. It does not change the price you pay. Some buttons still go to the company’s own site, because we have not joined every program yet. The verdict does not depend on a commission.Full disclosure.

Beehiiv and Substack both publish a newsletter, host a site around it, and let readers pay. They charge for that in opposite ways. Substack has no monthly plan. It keeps 10% when readers pay you. Beehiiv charges a plan once you want automations, ads, or paid subscriptions, and it says it keeps 0% of those subscriptions. The argument is that fee, plus whether you want Substack’s network or beehiiv’s tools.

Figures were checked on November 19, 2026. Substack’s cost article was updated October 29, 2026. The setup article for paid publications was updated November 2, 2026. Beehiiv’s prices are from the pricing page and the October 1, 2026 plan rename. We did not invent open rates or a private test of either editor.

Free publishing is not the same offer

Substack’s help center says publishing is free at any list size. There is no subscriber cap in that article. You can write, send, and grow without a plan. Paid subscriptions are optional. When they are on, the 10% applies.

Beehiiv Free is $0 up to 2,500 subscribers. It includes unlimited sends, a website, a podcast with a 5,000-download monthly cap, recommendations, and one digital product. It does not include automations, a custom domain, A/B tests, paid subscriptions, or the ad network. Past 2,500 free subscribers, you need a paid plan. Substack does not have that cliff.

Kit’s free plan is the third $0 option if what you want is a list of up to 10,000 and you do not need Substack’s network or beehiiv’s ads. That write-up is the Kit free plan review. This page stays with the two newsletter businesses.

What you pay when readers pay

Substack Beehiiv
Monthly platform fee $0 Free to 2,500. Lite from $59/month, or $49/month annual, at up to 1,000 subscribers
Cut of paid subscriptions 10% 0% on Lite and Pro
US card processing 2.9% + $0.30, as Substack lists it 2.9% + $0.30, as beehiiv lists it
Extra recurring fee 0.7% Stripe Billing on the Oct 29, 2026 help article Not listed as a separate Stripe Billing line on beehiiv’s pricing FAQ
Custom domain $50 once Included on Lite and Pro, not on Free
Automations Not a priced automation tier in the cost article None on Free. 10 live on Lite. Unlimited on Pro
Ads Not the product Substack’s cost page is selling Ad network on Lite and Pro, not on Free, and not in every region

Substack’s minimum prices, from the November 2, 2026 setup article, are $5 a month and $30 a year on US-dollar Stripe accounts. Other currencies can differ. A publication that turns on payments needs both a monthly and an annual plan. Yearly-only is not offered. A founding-member tier is optional and must cost more than the regular plans. Readers can pay more in two cases Substack names: tax a writer adds, and in-app purchases on iOS if you choose to raise the price to cover Apple’s fee. Substack’s 10% on in-app purchases is based on your web price.

An older Substack FAQ still describes the recurring billing fee as 0.5%. The help center article from October 29, 2026 says 0.7%, and it attributes that 0.7% to Stripe’s Billing price as of July 2024. We are not going to average them. Quote the help center, then look at one real Stripe payout. The line will be labeled.

Beehiiv’s paid plans are buckets, not a single price. At up to 1,000 subscribers, Lite is $59 a month or $588 a year. At up to 2,500, Lite is $79 a month or $69 a month billed annually. At up to 10,000, Lite is $139 a month or $119 annual. Pro at 1,000 subscribers is $109 a month or $95 annual. Pro is the plan that removes branding, raises automations from 10 to unlimited, and adds a sponsorship storefront. A solo writer who is comparing Substack usually needs Lite, not Pro.

Existing beehiiv customers who were on the old Launch, Scale, and Max names move to the new prices at the first renewal on or after November 1, 2026. New signups are on Free, Lite, and Pro. A screenshot that still says Scale is the Lite shelf.

A simple crossover, labeled as arithmetic

Ignore Stripe for a moment, because both sides describe a 2.9% plus 30 cent US card fee. The difference is Substack’s 10% versus beehiiv’s subscription.

  • Beehiiv Lite at the 1,000-subscriber annual rate is $49 a month. Ten percent of paid revenue equals $49 when readers pay you $490 in that month.
  • The same Lite plan month to month is $59. The matching revenue is $590.
  • If paid revenue is $200 a month, Substack’s 10% is $20. Lite costs more than that 10%, before you count anything else Lite includes.
  • If paid revenue is $1,000 a month, Substack’s 10% is $100. Lite at $49 or $59 costs less than the 10%, and the gap is the start of an argument for switching.

This is arithmetic from the published rates. It is not a beehiiv or Substack calculator. It ignores annual reader plans, refunds, tax, Apple’s fee, and the fact that a writer with 1,000 free subscribers and 30 paying readers is in a different beehiiv bucket than a writer with 8,000 free subscribers. Run it on your last three months of paid revenue, not on a hoped-for list.

Ads can move the beehiiv side. Beehiiv says the ad network is on Lite and Pro, not during the trial, and not in every region. We did not copy a payout table. If your country is excluded, do not put ad income in the crossover. Substack’s cost page does not sell an equivalent ad network. Its growth story is the recommendation network and Notes.

Discovery versus tools

Substack’s features page describes Recommendations, Notes, leaderboards, chat, podcast hosting, and video. Notes is the short-form feed. Chat can be limited to paid or founding subscribers. Podcast hosting is described as free of a monthly hosting fee, with RSS to Apple Podcasts and Spotify. A Substack page comparing itself with Patreon says more than 50% of new subscribers come from inside Substack. That is Substack’s figure, not an audit. It is also the reason people accept the 10%. If your last twenty subscribers came from a recommendation or from Notes, the fee is buying distribution. If they all came from your own links, you are paying 10% for software you could rent another way.

Beehiiv’s network is recommendations too, including on the free plan, plus the ad network and a website with more room once you pay. Lite’s 10 automations cover a welcome series and a few branches. Substack’s cost and features pages we read do not sell a visual automation builder as a line item. If the business is “someone joins and gets three emails,” beehiiv Lite or Kit Creator is the tool that documents that job. The Kit comparison is Beehiiv vs Kit.

Beehiiv Free stops at 2,500 people and does not let you charge. Substack lets you charge from the first subscriber, at the cost of 10% plus Stripe. A writer who wants five paying readers and no monthly bill should not buy Lite to feel professional. A writer who is about to cross 2,500 free readers, or who wants a custom domain without a one-time $50 on Substack, is already in a paid conversation.

Courses, coaches, and the wrong job

A coach who sends a letter so people will buy a program is not choosing a publication business. Substack’s 10% applies to paid subscriptions, not automatically to a course sold on another checkout. Beehiiv’s 0% applies to paid subscriptions and, on their account, they do not take a platform cut of digital products either. The course itself still needs a home if students expect lessons, drip, and a login. Systeme.io and Kajabi are that conversation. Using Substack chat as the classroom is a choice you can test with ten people. It is not the same product as a course host.

If the letter is the thing people subscribe to, stay on this page. If the letter is a launch calendar, read email for a first online course and pick a tool that has sequences on the plan you can afford.

Choose Substack

  • You want zero monthly software cost, including after the list passes 2,500.
  • Recommendations and Notes are how strangers find you.
  • Paid revenue is still small enough that 10% is cheaper than Lite.

Choose beehiiv

  • You want 0% of paid subscriptions and you will use Lite’s tools.
  • You want automations, a custom domain, or the ad network.
  • Your paid revenue is high enough that 10% costs more than the plan.

Sources we checked

Pricing checked: November 19, 2026. Confirm on the vendor’s site before you buy. The $490 and $590 crossover figures are our arithmetic, not a published break-even from either company.

Questions people ask before they pay

Does Substack charge a monthly fee?

No. Substack’s help center, updated October 29, 2026, says publishing is free no matter how many subscribers you have. If you turn on paid subscriptions, Substack keeps 10% of each subscription payment. Stripe charges its own fees. A custom domain is optional and listed at a one-time $50.

Does beehiiv take a cut of paid subscriptions?

Beehiiv’s pricing FAQ says no. You pay the plan, and Stripe’s fee still applies. Beehiiv describes that fee as 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction. The free plan does not include paid subscriptions. Those start on Lite.

Which is cheaper at 1,000 subscribers?

If everyone is free, Substack is $0 with no subscriber cap, and beehiiv’s free plan also covers 1,000 people because it allows 2,500. If you want automations, ads, or a paid tier with a 0% platform fee, beehiiv Lite at the up-to-1,000 bucket is $59 a month, or $49 a month when billed annually at $588 a year. Substack stays at $0 plus 10% of whatever readers pay.

What are the Stripe fees on Substack?

The October 29, 2026 help article lists 2.9% plus $0.30 per US card payment, plus 0.7% for Stripe Billing on recurring payments. It says the 0.7% figure is Stripe’s Billing price as of July 2024. An older Substack FAQ page still says the recurring billing fee is 0.5%. Use the help-center article as the current write-up, and read the Stripe line on a real payout before you budget the 0.7%.

Can I sell a course from either one?

Beehiiv lets you sell digital products, with a cap of one product on Free and three on Lite, and its CEO has described courses and coaching as things creators sell that way. It is not a lesson-and-quiz classroom. Substack’s features page describes posts, podcasts, video, and chat. It does not describe a course school. If the course is the product, use a course host and let the newsletter be the newsletter.

When does beehiiv’s subscription beat Substack’s 10%?

On arithmetic, 10% of paid subscription revenue equals a $49 monthly beehiiv bill when that revenue is $490 a month, and it equals a $59 bill at $590. That ignores Stripe, which both charge, and it ignores ads or products. It is a sketch, not a quote from either company. If paid revenue is far below that, Substack’s lack of a subscription is the cheaper published deal.